Add new comment

Beth Barron's picture

Bottling Civility: Engaging Politely about Controversial Topics

"Understand this, my dear brothers and sisters! Let every person be quick to listen, slow to speak, slow to anger.” James 1:19

bottling civilityHow can we talk about controversial topics in a meaningful way?

I’ve witnessed or been in on some contentious political discussions in the last several months. Some on Facebook have included profanity and name calling—and this among believers.

On the other hand, I have the privilege of participating with a small, but diverse group of believers in some mind-expanding discussions on potentially explosive topics. Our conversations have been exhilarating—and humbling. The group is a multi-generational gathering of men and women, multi-racial, probably from multiple political parties. We’ve had the opportunity both to express different viewpoints honestly and to realize the limitations of our perspectives.

I wish I could bottle the essence of that group and sell it in vending machines all over the world.

So I am going to offer you three bottles of civility beginning this month. The first bottle of civility is to open with your family, and do I ever need a swig of it.

My husband, adult children, in-laws and I have different opinions on many issues. Those who know me well would not be surprised to know that I have failed often in the last few months to engage in civil discourse with my family. Oh, we’ve talked all right, but it hasn’t always been civil.

So here are a few ingredients I am putting in my bottle of Civil Discourse—Family Flavor:

·         Love and respect. Keep focused on your family members’ good qualities and your history of positive relationship when you are talking with them. Don’t lose sight of the love and sacrifices that bind you together and maintain the relationship with your spouse, parents, in-laws or children.

·         The right time and place. Don’t talk to your spouse about controversial issues when he walks in the door from work or right when she is dropping off to sleep. More than once my husband has disengaged and said to me, “Do we absolutely need to talk about this right now, or can it wait?” Don’t initiate such a conversation while your spouse is prepping for a 12-person dinner party or in the middle of wallpapering the bathroom. Pray for wisdom and wait for the right time if you intend to have a tough conversation on a contentious topic.

·         A mutual desire to talk. Far too often I engage in ambush conversations: my family member is relaxing or helping me in the kitchen; I pounce. “Did you hear what I heard on the news? I am so mad I could spit.” No answer. (You can already tell this is not a discussion. This is an attack looking for a victim.) Some people are not interested in discussing their viewpoint. I can’t make them and my attack posture is uninviting. Both parties in a polite conversation must share a desire to talk.

·         A commitment to learn and understand. If you and your brother, sister, husband, child or in-law have a drastically different viewpoint on something, approach them with a genuine desire to understand how they came to that viewpoint. If you don’t want to understand their viewpoint and how they arrived at it, you are not looking for a conversation, you are looking for a podium. For example, my husband has a God-given responsibility to provide for the two of us, both now and in retirement years. That influences his position on financial decisions. I need to bear his responsibility in mind when I talk with him about finances.

·         Common ground. As you learn and listen to your family members, look for common ground. I have entered into discussions with my adult sons. We don’t see eye to eye on everything. I can belittle their perspectives or empathize with their values and recognize our common faith, even if we come to different conclusions. One approach shuts down communication. The other opens it up. We can choose whether we want argument and withdrawal or thoughtful discussion.

I hope you’ll stir up a batch of Civil Discourse—Family Flavor. It won’t guarantee agreement, but it will preserve relationships and open the door to future dialogues. It also has the side effect of teaching your children how to think and communicate graciously by example. And the ingredients will come in handy for your next two batches of Civil Discourse—Church Flavor and Community Flavor. See you in March.

Blog Category: 

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.