Before we throw stones at the Duggars…and some advice from a CPS pro

It’s been a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad week for the Duggars and their 19 Kids and Counting reality TV show. A few days ago a celebrity gossip tabloid reported that twelve years ago Josh, the oldest child, fondled five young girls, several of them his sisters. He was fourteen at the time. The tabloid took the police report public and the web has exploded with condemnation.
Parents Jim Bob and Michelle have been publicly shamed for calling it a “very bad mistake” and covering it up. Last night CNN’s Don Lemon and his guests slammed them for dealing with Josh through a religious lens of sin and repentance rather than acknowledging “the reality”: his actions are a crime and he should be reported to the police. (Really? Keep reading…)
The Learning Channel is deciding whether to continue producing the show. Viewers are deciding whether they will continue to watch it. Or permit their children to watch it. Many of us are listening to the uproar wondering how to respond to fellow-believers with wisdom and grace. And no doubt many families with a similar experience are watching this unfold in horror of what this all means for the way they handle their own children.

Full disclosure: Except for a few times while staying my Mom, I haven’t watched 19 Kids and Counting. But as a Christian with a public platform I empathize with the Duggars as they try to love their son and respond to his choices in a way that honors God and protects their family.
I hope we’re all trying to empathize. We should admit that we have very little understanding of this *rarely* talked about subject. When an older brother dishonors innocent little sisters like that we can’t imagine Jim Bob and Michelle’s feelings of betrayal, the heartbreak, the revulsion, the false guilt (How could I not have protected my daughter?) or the desperation (We have got to get our son *out* of the house).
This is the most urgent concern a family faces. Your girls simply *have* to be safe in your home.
When this behavior happens Dad and Mom are faced with hard choices: turn their son over to law enforcement/children’s protective services. Or try to find a redemptive, life-saving situation where they can be personally counseled by a mentor or professional, preferably a Christian, over a significant period of time until trust is rebuilt and the son seems genuinely repentant and restored.
When this first happened in 2002 Josh admitted fondling the girls to his parents. He did it with his clothes on and the girls’ clothes on, mostly when the girls were asleep in the Duggar home. According to the police report the Duggars held a family meeting and made changes to their house rules, including sleeping arrangements and bathroom use. They treated it as a young boy’s sexual exploration with his sisters.  Not a crime.
But then in 2003 Josh again fondled a young girl. And the next day his parents removed him from the house. For four months he did hard labor with a friend who ran a construction business who also mentored him. When he seemed repentant and restored he was allowed to return home. Josh confessed his fondling to a state trooper who was a friend of his Dad’s. The trooper gave him a stern talk, but no police report was filed. When Josh first began to seriously court Anna he disclosed to her and her father the terrible choices he had made years earlier that almost ruined his life.
Crime and punishment? Or sin and restoration? Maybe you have faced the same nightmare. If so my heart goes out to you. I asked a Christian friend who has worked in children’s protective services for years about how parents should respond.
First of all my friend responded that this happens far more often than any of us realize. Secondly, in his professional opinion, he would not consider what Josh did a crime. Neither was his parents’ decision to not turn him over to authorities (at least in my state South Carolina, or, from what I can tell, Arkansas). If a counselor had called it in to him he would not have even called in the police. He would have interviewed the Duggars to see if they were taking steps to protect their daughters and make sure it didn’t happen again. From what he knows he thinks the Duggars made wise choices in how they handled Josh.
But he also admitted that another colleague might have responded differently. And this is the crap shoot that any parent faces when they think about calling in the authorities.
Parents who find themselves in such a nightmare need wise counsel and much prayer as they consider:
…Is the nature of my son’s offense so serious that he needs more help than we can give him? (If he’s older and the violation was much worse than Josh’s, then my friend tells me you can be held liable for not reporting.)
…Should I take my child to a counselor who specializes in sexual abuse? Even if that counselor doesn’t offer the forgiveness and restoration of the gospel in his life?
…Should I take them to a Christian counselor who doesn’t deal with juvenile sexual abuse very often? (Note: If you take your child to a professional, even your pastor, in most states they are required to report your son to Child Protective Services or the police.)
…Is it best for my son (and my daughter[s]) for him to be placed in a protective shelter or a foster family?
…If he is convicted am I prepared to make the 2-3 hour drive to the correctional facility to stay connected to him?
…Do I want to completely give up what ultimately happens to him in the system, letting others determine if or when he might be repentant and trustworthy?
…Am I doing enough to protect my girls?
…Do I really want God’s justice and restoration for my children more than I want to avoid the conflict?
These are excruciating choices for a parent. Who among us feels competent to make this decision for another Mom or Dad?
I think many parents would have done what the Duggars did: confer with trusted friends or the leaders of their church and, if they had the support system, send their son to live with a family friend who would work him hard during the day and love him hard in the evenings as they shepherded him back to repentance and restoration.
This option would also enable parents to focus on the shepherding of their daughters and the healing they need. (The Duggars arranged for counseling for all the victims.) It would also guard their privacy in the progress.
If I could sit down with the tabloid, CNN and other reporters over a cup of coffee I would like to ask them…what is gained by this disclosure? If you are so concerned for the victims, why dredge this up and make it a terrible ordeal for them?
Are you concerned about justice? As a minor touching a minor Josh was punished and restored. In his apology he states that he asked forgiveness of those he offended and of Jesus. His sisters told the police they felt safe in their home. He now seems to be a healthy Dad with three and counting children of his own.
Should every brother who touches his sister be condemned and even convicted as a criminal? Does the State always know best how to shepherd our children? Who *is* the State? Is it my friend? Or his colleague who might have turned them over to the police?
CNN was especially harsh in condemning this as a crime and a cover-up. But where is the reporting on the law and how Child Protective Services handles this kind of touching?
What I hear in almost every news story is the charge of hypocrisy. The Duggars make a strong stand for virtuous, Biblical families. They also oppose homosexuality and gay marriage. Further, Josh works for the Family Research Council which lobbies for Biblical family values in Congress and campaigns for pro-life, pro-traditional marriage candidates. To those who reject the Bible as true north on these matters this is terrible hypocrisy.  To millions of Christians it isn’t.
While I want to give the Duggars the benefit of the doubt, I do wonder… I can understand how they handled this, but I do wonder why, just a year or two after the 2006 police investigation (triggered by an email from Oprah’s production team, but dropped because the statute of limitations had expired)…why the Duggars would put their family on a national TV platform with this chapter in their family history. Did they tell The Learning Channel about their vulnerability on this issue? Why Josh would go to work for the Family Research Council without telling them of his vulnerability. Can any high-profile Christian keep that kind of secret from investigative reporters?
It’s red meat. It’s the Progressive Holy Grail. You strike a blow to Evangelicals, pro-lifers, traditional marriage proponents, FRC, Republicans, home-schoolers, social conservatives all at once—seven in one blow!
As we have opportunity I hope we surround all parents going through something like this with love and support. With tenderness and protection for the girls. And tenderness and accountability for the boys.
The thing that troubles me the most from this episode is how CNN condemned the Duggars for seeing this episode as a matter of sin and forgiveness rather than crime and punishment. They condemned them for being so out of touch with reality.
I believe the reality is: touching your sister through her clothes may not be a crime. But it is a sin. And you are guilty, guilty before the greatest judge of all. Sin is more deadly than we can ever suspect. Its consequences ripple out in ways we cannot control. All of us have sinned and are far more guilty than we can ever imagine. But the good news is…we are far more loved than we ever dare hope. And the One who loves us died for our sin to give us a life of blessing and forgiveness. A spirit of power and love and self-control.
I hope that is the message that rolls down like mighty waters from the Duggars continued story. Whether the cameras are rolling or not.
Lael Arrington
Faith and Culture: Live wisely │ Love well

Lael writes and speaks about faith and culture and how God renews our vision and desire for Him and his Kingdom. She earned a master's degree (MAT) in the history of ideas from the University of Texas at Dallas, and has taught Western culture and apologetics at secular and Christian schools and colleges. Her long-term experience with rheumatoid arthritis and being a pastor’s wife has deepened her desire to minister to the whole person—mind, heart, soul and spirit. Lael has co-hosted a talk radio program, The Things That Matter Most, on secular stations in Houston and Dallas about what we believe and why we believe it with guests as diverse as Dr. Deepak Chopra, atheist Sam Harris and VeggieTales creator Phil Vischer. (Programs are archived on the website.) Lael has authored four books, including a March 2011 soft paper edition of A Faith and Culture Devotional (now titled Faith and Culture: A Guide to a Culture Shaped by Faith), Godsight, and Worldproofing Your Kids. Lael’s writing has also been featured in Focus on the Family and World magazines, and she has appeared on many national radio and television programs. Lael and her husband, Jack, now make their home in South Carolina.


  • Sue Bohlin

    The best yet

    Lael, this is the best analysis of the Duggar situation I've yet read. Bless you. 

  • Lael Arrington

    Thanks, Sue. This is being reported as if Josh committed a crime

    But filling out a police report does not equal the finding of a judge or jury. The officer has to list what statute he thinks applies to the behavior he is investigating. But it's not a legal finding that he committed a crime. My CPS friend could not believe how the media is making another victim out of a 13/14 yr old boy.

    Grieves me deeply.I'm all for victim protection of the young girls. We don't really know how they might have been marked by their experience in 2002/2003. But they all told the police they felt safe in their home.



  • jL

    You’re missing an important aspect

    Over and over again I read fellow Christian responses in support of the Duggars. But one thing I see that's escaped them is that the Duggars are not part of Mainstream Christianity, nor a healthy church/homeschooling program. They are entrenched in fringe and abusive theologies and practices. Before holding the banner high for the Duggars, research the Quiverfull movement, and their homeschooling curriculum which colors their whole world: ATI/Gothard-ism. It is because the Duggars are entrenched in this fringey, abusive perspective that they cannot even see nor take appropriate measures to help their son or protect their daughters. They signed up to do a reality TV show only 1 year after a their children were molested by the eldest brother. Doesn't that concern anyone? Jim Bob ran for office, his son worked in a Christian values advocacy group in Washington DC… Shows no humility…. They are not above reproach… What business do they have in any type of public or leadership positions? They did not fall far from the tree. Gothard had the same hidden, delusional type of life. When we defend such Fringe Christian brothers and sisters, we are no better than Job's friends… Offering a whole lot of godly sounding but useless advice because you've missed the invisible problem: the abusive system they're a parent of. You've become enablers if you only see this as a fight against progressives. There are false biblical teachings underlying the Duggar situation… THAT's what ought to concern us. Otherwise… Children will continue to be unprotected… And people like you are helping that along.  CPS worker, you say? Maybe you ought to consider another profession. Abuse has happened because the Duggars are in an abusive church system… Aberrational Christian theology. By the way, molestation runs so rampant in quiver full and Gothard movements. Gothard himself has molested at least 34 women. As Christians we ought to note that before flying the Duggar flag high.

    • Lael Arrington

      Accusations but no evidence

      Dear jL,

      Do you think maybe your tone is just a little harsh? And what about all these unsubstatiated accusations. What are the "false Biblical teachings" underlying the Duggar situation?  Or the abuses in the church system? What are the aberrations of their theology?You offer not one specific.

      You attack the Duggars for being part of a strongly separatistic homeschooling group. Makes me wonder if you have ever read Jeremiah 35. In it God commends the Rechabites for being a militantly separatistic non-mainstream fringe group. (I'm sure they home-schooled as well)

      Jeremiah 35:8-10   8 We have obeyed the voice of Jonadab the son of Rechab, our father, in all that he commanded us, to drink no wine all our days, ourselves, our wives, our sons, or our daughters,  9 and not to build houses to dwell in. We have no vineyard or field or seed,  10 but we have lived in tents and have obeyed and done all that Jonadab our father commanded us. 

      They chose to live in tents like Abraham ourside Judah's cities. No fields or vinyards. They put the followers of Bill Gothard in the shade. Yet they loved God and obeyed him. So God exalted them.

      Jeremiah 35:18-19  Because you have obeyed the command of Jonadab your father and kept all his precepts and done all that he commanded you,  19 therefore thus says the LORD of hosts, the God of Israel: Jonadab the son of Rechab shall never lack a man to stand before me." 

      God doesn't seem to care how fringe or mainstream we are. He wants our hearts. He sees the Duggars hearts. Not us.

      They raised a son whose heart was so tender that he came to them when he gave in to temptation and told his parents. He was evidently torn up about it. 

      Now in this we agree…why would you put your family with that weakness on a reality TV show? And why would Josh not tell FRC about his past? I raised these questions in my post. I'm not whitewashing the  fact that they made these decisions.They will give account to God for the decisions they made.

      I was never a homeschooler. I had big questions about Gothard starting in the 80's. But I've known families who followed his principles pretty closely and they have some of the most outstanding Christian families I've ever known. Parents and kids who are sold out to Jesus. Raising godly families of their own. 

      Finally, when you are leveling accusations, please take a closer look at the text of what I wrote. You said, "CPS worker, you say? Maybe you ought to consider another profession." I am not a CPS worker. That would be my friend who worked for years in the system, both as a case worker, then as Department head supervising all the case workers in one of America's State Capitals. He speaks from more first-hand knowledge than either of us will ever have and is also a sold-out follower of Jesus.

      You criticize the Duggars for a lack of humility. Please consider speaking with more humility in your post. I welcome a reasoned dialogue. But so far you have appealed to ad hominem attacks. Not evidence.

      Even if you can point to Gothard principles that may be questionable Biblically, how do you know how closely the Duggars adhered to his teaching? Some of the families I know use some of his teaching/resources and reject others. Please come back when you are ready to offer evidence of what the Duggars (not Bill Gothard) believed that showed disobedience to God or his Word.

      Otherwise let's let our brothers and sisters in Christ stand or fall before our mutual Master.

      Lael Arrington